Meth dealer enters guilty plea in
murder trial
By Abby Morris
STAR STAFF
amorris@starhq.com
An Elizabethton man charged with second-degree
murder in the December 2000 death of Justin Vanover entered
a guilty plea after having the charge plea bargained down
to reckless homicide in Criminal Court Friday afternoon. Ralph
"Mack" Myers, 115 Bluefield Ave., was sentenced to eight years
in jail.
Myers was originally charged with second-degree
murder after Vanover, 23, died as the result of an overdose
on methadone that he had gotten from Myers. Clifton Corker,
Myers' attorney, worked out a plea bargain with the state
to have the charge lowered to reckless homicide in exchange
for a guilty plea.
"They're letting you plead down from second-degree
murder to reckless homicide," said Judge Robert Cupp, who
presided over the plea. "They're letting you plead down from
a Class A felony all the way down to a Class D felony."
Myers told the court that at the time of Vanover's
death, he was dating Vanover's mother, Susan Stansberry, and
that he was participating in a methadone clinic.
"I was going to the methadone clinic and he (Vanover)
knew that I was going," Myers said.
According to Myers, Vanover had a friend by the
name of David who was undergoing treatment at the same clinic
as Myers and that the week of the incident, David had been
unable to attend his treatment session.
"He asked me if he could have some methadone
for David," Myers said. "I said, 'This is for your friend?'
and he said 'Yes' and assured me that it was for David."
Myers stated that he gave Vanover approximately
22 milligrams of methadone, which is less than one-fourth
of the dosage that Myers was on at the time. Myers testified
that after giving Vanover the methadone, he was unable to
find the container he had kept his methadone in.
The next day, Myers said, someone called him
and Stansberry and told them that an ambulance was at Vanover's
apartment. Myers said that he and Stansberry then went to
Vanover's apartment and found the emergency crews attempting
to revive Vanover.
According to the findings on the autopsy ordered
by investigators, Vanover died from a methadone overdose.
Corker informed the court that a medical doctor was consulted
by the defense and according to that doctor's findings, the
amount of methadone given to Vanover by Myers was not enough
to have resulted in an overdose.
The original charge of second-degree murder could
have carried a sentence of 15-25 years that would have been
non-probatable, meaning that probation would not have been
an option for alternative sentencing. Second-degree murder
is defined in the Tennessee Code Annotated as "the knowing
killing of another."
The offense which Myers pleaded to, reckless
homicide, carries a sentence of four-eight years and the court
has the option of sentencing Myers to probation as an alternative
sentence. The Tennessee Code Annotated states that reckless
homicide occurs when a criminally negligent act occurs and
that action was the cause of death.
A co-defendant in the case involving the death
of Vanover is Felicia English, who was Vanover's girlfriend
at the time of his death. She is charged with criminally negligent
homicide.
According to her indictment, English acted with
criminal neglect "by failing to render aid to Justin Vanover
when Felicia English should have been aware of substantial
and unjustifiable risk that death could occur..."
English had a trial date set for February of
this year, but the trial has been put on hold and a new court
date has not yet been set.